HistoryData
general2014

Landmark involuntary manslaughter case

July 13, 2014

The Michelle Carter texting suicide case set a legal precedent on criminal liability for encouraging another person's suicide via electronic communication.

Quick Facts

Year
2014
Category
general

Key Facts

Victim
Conrad Roy III, age 18
Defendant
Michelle Carter, age 17 at time of offense
Verdict
Guilty of involuntary manslaughter
Initial sentence
2.5 years in prison
Time actually served
11 months and 12 days
Roy's cause of death
Carbon monoxide poisoning (suicide)

By the Numbers

18
Victim
17
Defendant
2.5
Initial sentence
11
Time actually served

Location

Map of Massachusetts, United StatesMap of Massachusetts, United StatesMassachusetts, United States

Cause → Event → Consequence

Cause

Conrad Roy III, who had a history of mental health struggles and had been under psychiatric care, repeatedly expressed a desire to die to his girlfriend Michelle Carter. Over the course of their relationship, Carter sent Roy numerous text messages encouraging him to act on these desires, culminating in a phone call on July 12, 2014.

Event

On July 12, 2014, Roy died by suicide in his truck using carbon monoxide. During a critical phone call, Carter instructed a hesitant Roy to return inside the vehicle as it filled with the gas. A Massachusetts bench trial, presided over by Judge Lawrence Moniz, found Carter guilty of involuntary manslaughter, concluding her words coerced Roy to his death.

Consequence

Carter was initially sentenced to two and a half years in prison, later reduced to 15 months, of which she served just over 11 months. The case, widely called the 'texting suicide case,' prompted broad legal and ethical debate about the limits of criminal responsibility for speech and the role of electronic communications in coercion.

Timeline Context

Timeline around 201420142011201220132015201620172014 FIFA World Cup — 20th FIFA World Cup, held in BrazilEuropean migrant crisis — 2010s migrant crisis in the European UnionRussian annexation of Crimea — annexation of Crimea into Russia in 20142014 Gaza War — war fought between the Israel Defense Forces and the Hamas-governed Gaza Strip during 2014January 2014 — month of 20142014 Formula One World Championship — 65th season of Formula One motor racing2014 Summer Youth Olympics — 2014 edition of the Summer Youth Olympics2014 Asian Games — 17th edition of the Asian Gamesdeath-of-conrad-roy-2014